Title:
Authors:
| criterion | max | score |
| abstract informative about methods and results | 3 | |
| introduction insightful on background and motivation |
|
|
| well-chosen starting point for new research (e.g. existing algorithm) |
|
|
| clear and sensible motivation for new approach (e.g. new algorithm) | 2 | |
| well-designed new approach (avoiding arbitrary heuristics) |
|
|
| precise and reproducible description of new approach |
|
|
| sensible implementation decisions (code reuse, choice of PL, etc.) |
|
|
| sufficiently conclusive experiments (large datasets, lesion studies, etc.) |
|
|
| detailed, reproducible description of experiments |
|
|
| understandable graphical presentation of results |
|
|
| clear, correct analysis of the statistical significance of results |
|
|
| insightful discussion of all major experimental results |
|
|
| logical organization and good technical prose style |
|
|
| correct spelling, grammar, and vocabulary |
|
|
| citations in all necessary places with full bibliographic data |
|
|
|
total |
|